Paid media agency red flags: 10 questions your agency should be asking

Effective paid strategy requires knowing these things first

If you’ve found yourself wondering how to tell if your paid media agency will actually drive pipeline, you’re not alone. Paid media performance has been a major pain for B2B marketers lately.  

In fact, 58% of B2B marketers said ad waste is a major issue, according to research from Demandbase and eMarketer. Over half of respondents said they’re wasting between 16% to 45% of their ad spend on irrelevant accounts. And only 19% of senior B2B marketers we surveyed said paid media reliably drives high-value opportunities. 

Your budgets are getting cut. Your attribution models are inconclusive. Your “leads” are going nowhere. And as AEO changes the role that paid media plays in demand generation, the problem is only getting worse.

Most of that waste stems from rinse-and-repeat paid media strategies that default to dumping more money into the problem. 

It’s time to break that cycle. Use the following questions to understand whether your paid media agency (or strategy) is built on real data or a template. We call it the Paid Media Truth Test: the 10 tough questions your paid media agency should be asking you — before they spend your money. 

If your paid media agency covers everything on this list, it’s a good sign they’ll actually help you drive pipeline. 

Who is your audience, really?

Why it matters: Saying that your ICP is “Fortune 1000 companies” doesn’t accomplish anything. To be effective, your agency needs to know which accounts are the actual target, and what stage of the buying cycle they’re in. If you don’t have that information, a good agency will dig into your existing sales calls, closed won deals, and CRM data to help paint that picture.

Your agency should also be pushing you to dig deeper than the same demographic data all your competitors are also using. At Iron Horse, we use platforms like Clay to identify high-fit accounts based on AI-informed intent signals (and not just topic/keyword-based intent that everyone is overindexed on), activating audiences that are uniquely yours. 

What’s your current media mix, and how’s it performing?

Why it matters: Your paid media agency needs to know what channels you’ve tried, what you spent, and what got results in order to make informed recommendations (and help you avoid repeating mistakes).

Here’s an example: One of our clients was convinced that LinkedIn ads were a waste of money. When we dug deeper, we saw they were targeting by skill keywords instead of by job titles, blowing their budget on a massive list. By asking questions, we helped them avoid blocking an effective channel over a setup mistake. 

Is your segmentation actually built, or just assumed?

Why it matters: An audience that’s defined but not operationalized is just wishful (and expensive!) thinking.

Make sure your paid media agency asks to double check the actual targeting settings running in your platform. At Iron Horse, we look beyond the strategy doc to make sure targeting is built on tangible job titles and account lists, not just nice-to-haves. We also ensure each element is backed by hard data, and not just assumptions. 

What content do you have, and does it match your buyer’s journey?

Why it matters: Incorrectly mapped content can become a major waste of money. Your paid media agency should review and recommend the best content for your campaign based on your target audience’s propensities and place in the buyer journey — not just what’s new, or what’s been used before.

For instance, if someone clicks your top-of-funnel display ad and lands on content that’s irrelevant or too in-depth for what they expect, you’ll probably lose that lead. The right partner will help you match buyers with what they need at that moment.

Are your CRM and martech stack actually set up and connected?

Why it matters: Without the right setup, you risk either wasting conversions or flooding your sales team with unqualified names. Your paid media agency should take the time to understand your marketing maturity — asking how your leads get scored and routed in your marketing automation platform and/or CRM. This helps ensure your agency creates a campaign you can actually act on. 

Whether your stack’s not set up to score leads effectively, or you haven’t worked out the right logic for your business, a good agency should make those adjustments before sinking money into a campaign. At Iron Horse, our internal MOps team reviews your integrations and setup as a standard part of our process so your media dollars don’t go to waste. 

How are you handling attribution?

Why it matters: Bad attribution leads to bad decisions, like cutting or doubling down on the wrong channels — especially in the age of zero-click. Someone might see an ad, never click, and still show up later on your site as direct traffic, with nothing linking back to what actually reached them. 

That’s why the right agency partner will ask how much you’re leaning on first-touch or last-touch models, then help implement smarter solutions. At Iron Horse, we build influence reports that catch what standard attribution misses, always being transparent about what’s a real signal versus an educated guess. 

What’s your follow-up strategy?

Why it matters: You waste leads when your conversions go to a cold sales call or a generic landing page. Your paid media agency should help you avoid that by considering what happens after someone converts.

For instance, a lead from third-party content syndication may not remember your brand from that one offsite download. Even if they do, they likely aren’t ready for a call from your sales rep. A five-to-seven-touch email nurture and digital retargeting structure is probably a better approach. 

What’s your budget, relative to your target list?

Why it matters: An underfunded target list isn’t worth running because it won’t work. Your paid media agency should be honest about what you need to spend, adjusting your target list or budget to get the results you need.

At Iron Horse, we provide clear benchmarks for how much to spend per account per month. For example, one of our clients had initially budgeted for 10,000 accounts at a level that could only reach 5% of them. After we worked together to adjust the budget and list size, penetration rose to 80%.

Can we talk to your sales team?

Why it matters: While your product team will give you the optimistic view, your sales team will tell you the actual objections coming up in conversations. 

Your paid media agency should want to hear how sales talks about the product where the business actually stands in the market. This also helps sales and marketing teams get on the same page, preventing bigger issues down the line.

Can we check your data to see what’s really winning deals? 

Why it matters: Most teams assume a lead is “good” because a tool labeled it that way. You can find what’s actually working by reviewing your sales calls, sales team’s notes, and win/loss data. 

Your paid media agency should ask to look at your closed-won data in your CRM from the last few months so they can reverse-engineer how and why those deals closed. At Iron Horse, we like listening to the sales calls themselves to hear the objections that came up, and how sales teams overcame them. 

Real partners ask the hard questions

If this Paid Media Truth Test feels challenging, that’s the point. 

Any agency can regurgitate yesterday’s approaches, telling you what you want to hear. The trustworthy ones will put in the effort up front — telling you where your strategy is falling short, and doing something about it. 

We may not always know exactly what will work when we start. But at Iron Horse, we follow the data with confidence, working with you to get it right.

That’s the difference between a paid media vendor and a paid media partner.

‍